Breakfast & Brunch in Bay Shore & Patchogue, NY

Order Now

Signature pancakes • Award-winning French toast • Omelettes • Belgian waffles • Breakfast burritos • Shrimp & grits • Chicken & waffles • Cold brew • Signature pancakes • Award-winning French toast • Omelettes • Belgian waffles • Breakfast burritos • Shrimp & grits • Chicken & waffles • Cold brew • Signature pancakes • Award-winning French toast • Omelettes • Belgian waffles • Breakfast burritos • Shrimp & grits • Chicken & waffles • Cold brew • Signature pancakes • Award-winning French toast • Omelettes • Belgian waffles • Breakfast burritos • Shrimp & grits • Chicken & waffles • Cold brew • Signature pancakes • Award-winning French toast • Omelettes • Belgian waffles • Breakfast burritos • Shrimp & grits • Chicken & waffles • Cold brew • Signature pancakes • Award-winning French toast • Omelettes • Belgian waffles • Breakfast burritos • Shrimp & grits • Chicken & waffles • Cold brew • Signature pancakes • Award-winning French toast • Omelettes • Belgian waffles • Breakfast burritos • Shrimp & grits • Chicken & waffles • Cold brew • Signature pancakes • Award-winning French toast • Omelettes • Belgian waffles • Breakfast burritos • Shrimp & grits • Chicken & waffles • Cold brew •

Pancakes & cold brew

One of many killer combos

Voted Long Island's best French toast. Best of LI 2020.

View the Menu

A few of the plates we are known for

Pancakes, French toast, omelettes and a little something more.

Order Now

Buttermilk's Own Signature Pancakes

Our full stack, served with your choice of one side.

Add Item

The HOLY Cannoli

Cannoli cream stuffed between two slices of our classic French toast.

Add Item

The Flamethrower

Spicy sriracha chicken, crumbled bleu cheese and scallions.

Add Item

Chicken & Waffles

Our Belgian waffle with signature crispy fried chicken and maple drizzle.

Add Item

Shrimp & Grits

Cajun shrimp over creamy cheese grits with cajun cream sauce.

Add Item

Skip the wait at the door

Join our waitlist

Add your name from your phone before you head over, and we'll let you know when your table is ready.

Patchogue

Join the Patchogue Waitlist (opens in a new tab)

Bay Shore

Join the Bay Shore Waitlist (opens in a new tab)

A room worth lingering in

Chandeliers over reclaimed wood, flowers on every table, and a staff we are proud of. Buttermilk's Farmhouse serves breakfast and lunch seven days a week in Bay Shore and Patchogue.

Order Now

Delicious and visually stunning drinks

Cold brew, lattes and the Samoa cappuccino. There is a glass for every plate on the menu.

Start Your Order

What Long Island is saying

Reviews from guests in Bay Shore and Patchogue.

Olivia

Great food. Very clean restaurant. We got the cinnamon roll pancakes. The Omelette Florentine and the avocado toast. The caramel macchiato was delicious. Service was fast and the staff are very friendly and polite. We brought kids and the restaurant was very accommodating. They have a broad kids menu.

Kay Cee

We heard of this place from Tik tok and we're elated that they opened up a location close by! The restaurant felt super welcoming and cozy, but the food was absolutely delicious. I am a huge fan of unique French toast and chicken and waffles. The main thing that stood out was the chicken served with the chicken and ... waffles. The chicken and batter had AMAZING flavor and was thin cut which had every bite full of flavor and melted in your mouth (truly perfect). The French toast was also super fluffy and packed with delicious buttery flavor. Definitely looking forward to trying out other items on the menu! Read More

Joanne Dorazio-Thier

The food and service were excellent. The tomato soup was so fresh and delicious. The toasted whole wheat bread tuna melt was the best I've ever had. Homemade and well worth coming back for. My husband said the same about his chicken and waffles. Excellent!

James Wood

We had a really good experience at Buttermilk’s Farmhouse. The food was fresh, flavorful, and came out quickly. Portion sizes were solid, and the menu is big with lots of options to choose from. The service was great overall, and our waitress was friendly, helpful, and attentive throughout the meal. We were seated ... right away with no wait, which was a nice bonus. The drink options were good, and the location is convenient right in the village of Bay Shore. Parking can be a little tricky at times. We ended up parking on the street, so just be mindful of metered parking. The only downside was the pricing on drinks and add-ons. Drinks were on the expensive side, and some of the upcharges felt a bit high, like being charged $1.50 for flavored syrup in a drink, which seemed excessive. Overall, it was a very enjoyable experience with great food, good service, and a lively atmosphere. Read More

Overhead spread of French toast, eggs benedict, a breakfast burrito and a club sandwich across a wooden table

Breakfast and lunch, catered

Did you know we do catering?

Whatever your occasion, however big or small, we have the perfect options to choose from. Birthdays, holiday parties, corporate events and wedding festivities.

See Catering

Frequently Asked Questions

What dishes are you best known for?

Our regulars come for the stacks: buttermilk pancakes poured from our own signature batter, the award-winning French toast we build on cinnamon brioche, and chicken and waffles finished with a maple drizzle. On the savory side, three-egg omelettes and loaded breakfast burritos each come with your choice of side.

What type of cuisine do you serve?

We are a from-scratch breakfast and brunch kitchen, with a full lunch menu of grilled cheeses, salads and sandwiches once the morning rush settles. It is classic American comfort cooking: farm-fresh eggs, homemade buttermilk biscuits and 100% real maple syrup.

What services do you offer?

Past the dining room, we handle catering for offices, showers and team breakfasts, and host private events with their own plated menu. Eating at home instead? Order takeout for pickup at either location, or have it brought over by delivery.

What areas do you serve?

We cook breakfast for two Suffolk County main streets: = 93 E Main St in Bay Shore and 76 W Main St in Patchogue. Guests drive in from across Long Island and the rest of Suffolk County for a table.